Is Netanyahu’s Trump card losing its power in Israel?
By CelebUD Newsroom —
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is heading to Washington for high-stakes discussions with US President Donald Trump, attempting to reinforce a personal and strategic bond that has long served as a cornerstone of his political appeal. Facing an upcoming election in late October, an ongoing corruption trial, and several unresolved regional conflicts, the veteran leader is seeking to demonstrate to voters at home that his influence in the American capital remains unmatched. However, amid a stalled conflict with Iran and growing policy rifts, questions are mounting in Jerusalem over whether his once-formidable relationship with Trump is beginning to falter.
A Fraying Alliance and Stalled Conflict
For decades, Netanyahu has positioned his fluent English, deep familiarity with American political culture, and close relationships with Washington decision-makers as evidence that he is uniquely qualified to lead Israel. That narrative reached its peak during Donald Trump's presidency, particularly when the United States joined Israel in direct military action against Iran. Yet as that joint war effort has hit a standstill, the political benefits of the partnership appear to be diminishing.
Reports indicating that Netanyahu convinced the White House of the war's viability and the likelihood of overthrowing the Iranian government have fueled underlying frustration in Washington. At the same time, the administration has shown a greater willingness to negotiate regional matters without consulting Israeli leadership. Disagreements have also erupted over Washington's willingness to explore the sale of F-35 fighter jets to Turkiye and a potential nuclear cooperation agreement with Saudi Arabia. Compounding these strains, members of the US Congress have expressed sharp disapproval regarding the violent actions of Israeli settlers, which recently included the extrajudicial detention of a American senator.
Resistance to Netanyahu has increasingly surfaced among prominent voices on the American political right. Former congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene and commentator Tucker Carlson have voiced criticism, while US Vice President JD Vance noted during an interview on Joe Rogan's podcast that certain Israeli officials appeared intent on undermining US-led diplomatic efforts with Iran. When asked aboard Air Force One regarding Israel's objections to selling F-35 aircraft to Turkiye, Trump offered a blunt assessment of his authority:
blockquote>"Nobody tells me what we should be selling"Calculated Diplomacy Ahead of October Elections
Netanyahu's official justification for the Tuesday meeting in Washington is attending the wake of the late Republican Senator Lindsey Graham. However, political observers argue the primary motivation is domestic political survival and strategic optics prior to the October vote.
Alon Pinkas, a former Israeli ambassador and consul general in New York, described the trip as an explicit attempt to manage perceptions back home. According to Pinkas:
blockquote>"The real reason Netanyahu’s got this visit [to Washington] is purely cynical," Pinkas told Al Jazeera. "He’s claimed that he’s flying all the way to the US to attend the wake of his apparently great friend [deceased Republican Senator] Lindsey Graham."Pinkas added that despite official discussion topics, the core objective remains personal political leverage:
blockquote>"Supposedly there’s an agenda, supposedly they’re going to talk about Iran, F-35s and Saudi Arabia’s potential nuclear deal," Pinkas said. "But really this is about two things: hoping to assure allies and critics within Israel that the relationship with Trump holds and, separately, hoping that Trump will again call for his pardon in the corruption trial," referencing Trump's previous public intervention in late 2025.Security analysts emphasize that Netanyahu arrives in the US capital under significantly diminished standing compared to prior visits. Ahron Bregman, a senior teaching fellow in War Studies at King's College London, noted the dramatic shift in perceptions within Washington political circles:
blockquote>"Netanyahu arrives in Washington at a time when even many around [Trump] are suspicious of him. He has become toxic in the US," Bregman observed. "He is regarded in the US – rightly or wrongly – as the one who dragged Trump into a war of choice that has turned into a strategic catastrophe. Nobody, not even Trump, will let him pretend to be the cleverest guy in the room. Those days are gone."Key Drivers of Friction Between Washington and Jerusalem
The accumulating policy disagreements between the two administrations highlight a expanding divide on core regional priorities:
| Policy Issue | US Administration Stance | Israeli Government Position |
|---|---|---|
| Iran War Strategy | Frustrated by a prolonged war and alleged efforts to derail diplomacy | Sought direct US military entry to weaken Tehran's leadership |
| Turkiye Defense Sales | Open to supplying F-35 stealth fighters to Ankara | Strongly opposed to arming a major regional competitor |
| Saudi Nuclear Deal | Exploring civil nuclear cooperation and bilateral trade agreements | Wary of nuclear expansion among neighboring states |
| West Bank Settler Actions | Critical of rising violence, including detention of a US senator | Accused of taking an indulgent approach toward settler groups |
Former Netanyahu aide and pollster Mitchell Barak pointed out that criticism of the Israeli prime minister is no longer restricted to political opponents, but spans across traditional center-right allies in the Republican Party:
blockquote>"Netanyahu’s had a tremendous track record with the US, but he’s burned a lot of bridges," Barak told Al Jazeera. "We’ve seen tension through Trump’s comments on the various F-35 sales, including most recently to Turkiye, as well as US criticism of Netanyahu at the start of the Iran war, so I’m not too sure if Trump’s going to be stumping for Netanyahu for all that much longer."Barak suggested that the US president could ultimately choose to redirect his support toward alternate Israeli political figures ahead of the election:
blockquote>"It could easily be that Trump declares Netanyahu was a great wartime leader, but that it was time for Israel to move on, before meeting with [other Israeli politicians] and endorsing a new prime minister for Israel."Conclusion
While Netanyahu's visit to Washington is unlikely to produce overt public hostility, the political foundation that previously bolstered his domestic reputation is facing severe pressure. The combination of an unfinished military campaign against Iran, escalating policy disputes with the White House, and skepticism across the political spectrum in Washington threatens to undermine his central campaign message. As Israeli voters prepare to go to the polls in late October, Netanyahu's ability to maintain his status as Israel's essential bridge to American power will undergo its most difficult test yet.
Reporting based on coverage by Al Jazeera.
Category: Politics